The
essays in Can
it Happen Here?: Authoritarianism
in America (Dey
Street Books,
March 2018, 496 pages, $11.99/12.18) vary
widely in accessibility, readability, and sense of audience. They
represent a set of, largely academic papers that may raise more
issues than they settle. Nevertheless, I came away, despite the
pessimism of some of the essays, with the sense that if Americans act
with courage and fortitude, our institutions will survive the Trump
assault on them. Most of
the writers, drawn from top, mostly American, universities suggest
that, while there seems to be world-wide skepticism toward liberal
democracy, we can weather the storm by relying on the checks and
balances established in the Constitution, maintaining a free press,
and the engagement of the electorate in the political process.
The
title of the book is drawn from Sinclair Lewis’s satirical novel,
It Can’t Happen Here, written
in 1936, which followed the career of a fictional governor, much like
Huey Long, the populist governor of Louisiana,
who took a run against Franklin Delano Roosevelt before his
assassination in 1936. Lewis’ autocratic, totalitarian
character, perhaps modeled on Adolf Hitler is elected president on a
platform of populism and traditional values. Sound familiar? The
title of Lewis’ book is turned into a question, which each of the
writers examine in their own fashion.
The
writers aredrawn
almost entirely from Academia and selected from elite institutions
dominated by the Ivy League and the University of Chicago. Including
editor Cass Sunstein, there were nineteen writers distributed thus:
Harvard – 5, Chicago – 5, Yale – 2, NYU – 2, Columbia – 1,
Princeton – 1, Cornell – 1, Duke – 1, George Mason – 1. In
terms of specialties, they were distributed this way: Law – 11,
Economics – 2, Diplomacy – 1, varied social sciences – 5.
Several were described as being multi-disciplinary. Given these
distributions of institutions and specialties, it’s little wonder
that many of the entries were jargon-filled and somewhat repetitive.
One
of the contributors, Samantha Powers, also happens to be married to
editor Sunstein, although I can see no reason why she doesn’t
belong in this distinguished group.
Can
It Happen Here? considers
whether the inclinations and indications from the Trump
administration can or will lead to the loss of our democracy and the
imposition/acceptance of an authoritarian form of government in the
United States. While, in his preface, Sunstein suggests that this
dark vision of what America might become isn’t yet happening, those
who can imagine such outcomes are writing and speaking about it. They
belong to a long history of those who’ve written about an
apocalyptic view of democracy and freedom.
The
essays range from thoughtful and insightful analyses of Donald
Trump’s mind and approach to stunningly difficult to read and
interpret research studies written for an academic audience. They
often are much in need of interpretation for even the intelligent lay
reader. As such, it seems to be a book in search of an audience who
can find enough sustenance to make it worth purchasing. It contains
too much jargon and too many statistics to be useful to the general
reader, and too little for the specialist.
The
general tenor of this collection is to suggest that while Trump, his
authoritarian vision and the alignment of his appointees towards the
very forces he campaigned against, while deeply upsetting and
destructive, is likely to fail as other efforts to exert control over
the government and people of America have failed in the past. But the
ride isn’t going to be pleasant and the destruction may take years
to heal. Since there are few examples of authoritarian or
anti-constitutional governance in this country, several of the
writers depend on authoritarian influences in Hungary and Poland,
which have pulled back from democracy. They also rely on the rise to
power of historical figures like Louis Bonaparte in France, Hitler,
and Mussolini, all of whom overthrew representative governments to
install autocratic rule before failing.
Most
of the essays strike a center-left middle ground, as one might expect
from a group of writers dominated by men (only two women contributed
chapters) trained in law who also teach it in elite settings.
There’s a strong presumption that the principles enshrined in the
Constitution and embodied in the checks and balances and the Bill of
Rights, with special emphasis on the role of the press, whose voice
is guaranteed by the First Amendment will prevail. Meanwhile, the
concerns of the unruly extremes of both parties is under-emphasized
as the writers place their faith in the good sense of the center.
Cass Sunstein
According
to Amazon, “Cass
R. Sunstein is the Robert Walmsley University Professor at Harvard
Law School, where he is the founder and director of the Program on
Behavioral Economics and Public Policy. He is by far the most cited
law professor in the United States. From 2009 to 2012 he served in
the Obama administration as Administrator of the White House Office
of Information and Regulatory Affairs. He has testified before
congressional committees, appeared on national television and radio
shows, been involved in constitution-making and law reform activities
in a number of nations, and written many articles and books,
including Simpler: The Future of Government and Wiser: Getting Beyond
Groupthink to Make Groups Smarter.”
Canit Happen Here?: Authoritarianismin America
(DeyStreet Boois, March 2018, 496 pages, $11.99/12.18) edited
by Cass Sunstein consists of seventeen essays edited and curated by
Cass Sunstein examining the rise of Donald J. Trump to the Presidency
of the United States and its possible outcomes. Relying on the
history of several authoritarian rises and failures in world history
as well as a social psychological approach to American predictions,
the book speculates about the possible continued world-wide rise of
authoritarian rule and its possibilities. With regard to the U.S.,
the essays hold out some optimism, assuming that Americans and our
institutions stand tall and act bravely. The essays are uneven, but
many deserve careful, thoughtful study. They are marred by their tone
and the denseness of the prose in some. The book was provided to me
by the publisher as a digital download through Edelweiss, and I read
it on my Amazon Fire.
No comments:
Post a Comment